Are WINE apps "native"?
Filed under:I was looking for a decent PDF editor for Linux (Xournal is great, but doesn't seem to allow inserting of images) when I came across this thread. Ignoring the fact that this person was more-or-less trolling, he's also wildly incorrect.
From the thread, where a poster asks about a native linux app:
> Any linux-native alternatives? Define "Linux native". Are the WINE libraries somehow less "native" than the gtk+ libraries or Qt libraries or...?
He also attempts to make an emotional appeal to defend his position:
I'm afraid that if your criteria is "something that wasn't specifically designed to run on Windows", you'll have to give up [...] Firefox
Since potentially labeling Firefox as "non-native" would be too much for any Linux user to swallow, he feels he's proved his point. So much for rationality.
The problem with reasoning such as this is that it attempts to remove the meaning of words. You can rationalize almost anything until any word can mean anything else. We are all children of the stars, we are the moon and the sun. Yay. Fucking hippy-talk. Whether or not it's true on some metaphysical level is unimportant. What is important is that words have a particular, agreed-upon meaning that allows us to communicate without digressing into the wonders of existence every time we want to ask for a glass of water or locate a piece of software.
This boils down to the simple fact that "native" has an actual definition which we can look up, if we aren't lazy trolls:
Native: being the place or environment in which a person was born or a thing came into being.
Oops.
Now WINE itself is certainly "native", but what about the applications that people run under it? Those are definitively not native, unless they were specifically written against the WINE libraries (some Google products come to mind).
In Oregon, we have non-native squirrels. Just because they thrive here does not make them native. Equivalently, just because you can run a Windows application under Linux does not make it "native".
My advice: buy a dictionary before you troll.






